In Defense of ‘Plan 9′

Plan 9 from Outer Space (** out of four)

Why give PLAN 9 FROM OUTER SPACE a two-star rating? I dunno, I can’t really justify it. All I can say is that few movies offer as much sweet, sweet joy as Ed Wood’s 1959 sci-fi opus. This film’s appalling anti-artistry is as funny as anything Hollywood has come up with in the last five decades.

To be fair, I haven’t seen it the way Wood intended. I’ve only seen the version where the MYSTERY SCIENCE THEATER guys are mocking it the whole way through. Still, you get the idea: flying saucers that look like hubcaps (when one of them gets blown out of the sky, I was reminded of the scene in BACK TO THE FUTURE where Doc Brown’s model Delorian bursts into flames); aliens played by B-movie actors wearing the galaxy’s loudest purple tee-shirts; establishing shots that don’t connect; out-of-left-field stock footage; unintentionally hilarious dialogue; etc.

Most of this was par for the course in the field Wood was working in: 1950s exploitation movies. But what makes PLAN 9 an unsurpassed triumph-of-sorts is its campy entertainment value. There’s something crazily bad going on in every scene, if not every shot. My favorite bit involves a detective who keeps absentmindedly pointing his gun at everything and everybody. Then there’s the alien who delivers the single greatest line in movie history: “You see? You see? Your stupid minds! Stupid! Stupid!”

Sure, it’s horrible. But it’s also fun, and harmless fun in any form is something to be celebrated.

Bookmark and Share

About the Author

Stephen Shupe is a Web writer, film critic and aspiring screenwriter living in Miami. He directed a handful of short films in college, winning a screenwriting award for the horror movie The Realm. Recently, he's gotten into the video-sharing business, and is currently at work on two film and play projects.